To Be Alone, or Not Alone?

Thu, 26 Mar 2015

President Langstaff has issued new guidance to Tribunals on when they should consider sitting with or without members, when there is a mix of claims before them – Birring v Michael Rogers and Carolyn Moore t/a Charity Link UKEAT/0388/14/RN.

Helen Barney succeeded in persuading President Langstaff that where there is a mix of jurisdictions before the Tribunal, consisting of complaints where a Judge is entitled to sit alone (section 4(2)-(3) ETA 1996), and those in which they cannot, a Judge is obliged to “actively and expressly” consider with the parties whether the claims that would ordinarily be heard by a judge sitting alone should be heard with members (pursuant to section 4(5) ETA 1996)).

The decision marks a shift from the earlier authority of Gladwell [2007] ICR 264 in which Elias J concluded that there was no legal duty for the Judge at the substantive hearing to invite observations on the composition of the Tribunal.  That case however concerned a single claim in which the default position was that a Judge would sit alone, and the parties had been asked for representations on the composition of the Tribunal in the notice of hearing. 

Representatives should therefore be alive to the need to address the Tribunal on composition in the event of a mixed jurisdictional claim.  

Please click here to view Helen Barney's profile.

Please click here for further information about the Employment Group.

Related articles

Personal Injury analysis: This analysis considers Master Cook’s judgment in RXK in which he sets out the circumstances in which the court will order an interim payment despite final quantification still being some years hence. It explains why this will be welcome news for claimant solicitors, even though no substantive decision was given in the case....

Date: Wed, 04 Dec 2019
No5 Barristers’ Chambers joined forces with Moore Blatch Solicitors to host an “inspiring evening” to mark the centenary of women in law....

Date: Thu, 28 Nov 2019
In her article published today in the New Law Journal, “Duty of care: Inadequate safety nets?"...

Date: Fri, 19 Jul 2019