Phil Bradley QC and Sharon Bahia prosecute fatal nightclub stabbing

Fri, 02 Feb 2018

Phil Bradley QC and Sharon Bahia of No5 Barrister’s Chambers are prosecuting the murder trial of an amateur football stabbed through the heart.

Ryan Passey, 24, was fatally wounded at Chicago’s nightclub, Rye Market, Stourbridge on August 6 last year.

Kobe Murray, 19, of The Brodway, Dudley, denies murder.

Mr Passey, an amateur footballer from Brierley Hill, was out with friends, and it is alleged that Murray plunged the blade into his chest after only ’some punches’ were thrown, prosecutors allege. He died in hospital after the attack.

Opening the case at Birmingham Crown Court, prosecutor Mr Phil Bradley QC said: “The prosecution’s case is that when he drove that knife into Ryan Passey, Kobe Murray did so deliberately and with the intention of causing Mr Passey really serious harm, and is therefore guilty of murder.”

During a police interview, Mr Murray did not answer questions, the court heard, but presented a statement through his solicitor, claiming he had been attacked at the club.

"If I used a knife it was in self-defence. I do not recollect the exact circumstances due to being attacked and being intoxicated," the statement said.

But Mr Bradley told jurors: "There is no suggestion that Ryan Passey or anyone in his group was armed with a knife or other weapon.

"It is against this backdrop that Kobe Murray's use of a knife should be measured.

"You may think that taking a knife to an unarmed man falls well short of reasonable or proportionate."

The trial continues. Follow the link to read a report of the trial so far on the Express and Star’s website:

Phil Bradley QC and Sharon Bahia are members of the Crime Group at No5.

Related articles

In December 2011 the client was convicted of murder but this was quashed in February 2015 following a successful appeal brought by Philip Rule to the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division). Mr Rule was instructed for the appeal and had not acted below....

Date: Wed, 02 Dec 2015
In one of Philip Rule’s ongoing cases before the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg (Minter v UK) the President of the First Section has decided to give notification of the application to the UK Government on 15 December 2015....

Date: Wed, 06 Jan 2016
Philip Rule, No5 Chambers, reports from the European Court of Huma Rights conference on the Crimes of the Past...

Date: Mon, 29 Feb 2016