Smiler Owners Admit Crash And Face Huge Fine

Tue, 26 Apr 2016

The owners of Alton Towers theme park face a multi-million pound fine following last summer’s Smiler crash.

Last Friday, in a hearing at North Staffordshire Justice Centre attended by victims of the crash, Merlin Attractions Operations Ltd indicated a guilty plea to breaching the Health and Safety at Work Act

No5 Chambers barrister Bernard Thorogood, representing the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) which brought the case, pointed out that due to the serious nature of the injuries, the size of the defendant and the very high fine likely to be imposed, the case should be moved to a higher court.

District Judge Jack McGarva agreed and adjourned until a date to be fixed at Stafford Crown Court.

Bernard Thorogood, for the HSE, said that since the ride opened in May 2013, there had not been a ‘a proper settled system’ for staff to follow when carriages stopped on-track, and that on the day of the smash a manual operator ‘overrode’ the ride’s controlling computer system, which had warned of the blockage.

Mr Thorogood said: "The upshot was that on June 2 although the computer-controlled system was correctly showing that at one of the furthest parts of the ride, the Cobra Loop, there was a stationary train, staff didn't see it and there wasn't a system to ensure they did see it. 

"They overrode the computer block on the system and sent the train around the ride. As a result those in the train were injured when their train came into collision with the stationary train.

"Those in the front row suffered the greatest physical injuries and the injuries were life-changing in many cases."

District Judge McGarva said: "This is a case which involved a very high culpability on the part of the defendant in my view and exposed the victims to a high likelihood of very serious harm.This is a case involving a large organisation which may be ordered to pay a very high fine.

The Smiler ride re-opened in March. 

Bernard Thorogood is a member of the Regulatory and Licensing Group as well as the Inquests, Public Inquiries and Coronial Law group at No5 Chambers.
Called to the Bar in 1986, after a Short Service Commission in HM Forces, he practises in the most serious categories of Health and Safety and other Regulatory cases.

Further media coverage can be found below -

The Times - Merlin admits guilt over Alton Towers rollercoaster crash
Daily Mail - Alton Towers owner facing huge fine after pleading guilty over Smiler crash
Sky News - Alton Towers guilty over rollercoaster crash
BBC News - Alton Towers admits Smiler ride safety breaches
The Guardian - Alton Towers owner pleads guilty over Smiler rollercoaster crash

CLICK HERE to view Bernard Thorogood's profile 

Related articles

Personal Injury analysis: This analysis considers Master Cook’s judgment in RXK in which he sets out the circumstances in which the court will order an interim payment despite final quantification still being some years hence. It explains why this will be welcome news for claimant solicitors, even though no substantive decision was given in the case....

Date: Wed, 04 Dec 2019
No5 Barristers’ Chambers joined forces with Moore Blatch Solicitors to host an “inspiring evening” to mark the centenary of women in law....

Date: Thu, 28 Nov 2019
In her article published today in the New Law Journal, “Duty of care: Inadequate safety nets?"...

Date: Fri, 19 Jul 2019