High Court rejects legal challenge to transgender prison policy

Mon, 05 Jul 2021

On Friday the Divisional Court handed down an important judgment in relation to the Ministry of Justice’s transgender prison policy.

 

The Claimant brought a claim arguing that her Article, 3, 8 and 14 rights under the Human Rights Act 1998 were violated, and she was indirectly discriminated against, by the Ministry of Justice’s prison policy on the care and management of transgender prisoners. Specifically, it was claimed that her rights were violated by having to be in the same prison as transgender women who have convictions for sexual or violent offences against women.

 

Dr Lamble was represented by Stuart Withers and Killian Moran of Kesar & Co Solicitors. Dr Lamble was granted permission to intervene to provide evidence in relation to the available statistics on transgender prisoners and their previous convictions for sexual and violent offences. Dr Lamble asked that the court be cautious in relation to making any factual findings based on the limited evidence available.

 

Lord Justice Holroyde importantly held 

 

“ I do not accept that the statistical evidence permits the conclusion, for which the Claimant contends, that a transgender prisoner is 5 or 6 times more likely than a non-transgender prisoner to commit a sexual assault on a non-transgender prisoner: that seems to be a misuse of the statistics, which in any event are so low in number, and so lacking in detail, that they are an unsafe basis for general conclusions.”

 

The Court went onto make findings regarding the single-sex exemptions under Schedule 3 of the Equality Act 2010. The Court accepted that they were permissive, and did not have to be applied. In any event, the Court found that the Secretary of State’s policy assessing a transgender prisoner’s risk would have performed a similar function if the exemptions applied.

 

The Judgment

 

Bent Bars Press Release

 

About me:

Stuart Withers specialises in public and prison law. He specialises in representing transgender clients in public law and civil claims arising from mistreatment in the criminal justice system. Stuart also advises Local Authorities and Schools in relation to transgender issues and education matters.

Related articles

Henry Pitchers QC, Philip Rule and Ramya Nagesh, instructed by Hodge Jones & Allen solicitors, have presented to the Coroner the family of Saskia Jones’s submissions aimed at exposing the dangers for the future from the failings seen in this case....

Date: Fri, 02 Jul 2021
Becket Bedford is currently embroiled in the intricacies of EEA deport notices...

Date: Fri, 25 Jun 2021
No5’s Philip Rule and Benjamin Harrison appeared in the Divisional Court in a claim seeking judicial review of the decision of the Secretary of State for Justice to refuse their client, DK, compensation for a miscarriage of justice pursuant to section 133 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988....

Date: Tue, 01 Jun 2021