Becket Bedford speaks about child refugees in TN/MA (Afghanistan) [2015] UKSC 40

Wed, 24 Jun 2015

The government has won a significant victory for its dealings with Afghan minors.  The Supreme Court, the highest court in the UK, has ruled that children are in no better position to win asylum than anyone else.  The court ruled that a failure to conduct family tracing in the past does not necessarily improve a person’s chance of winning asylum today.  In a further win for the government, the court ruled it had been lawful to delay a right of asylum appeal to children with limited leave of less than one year.

Attention must now shift to a concrete approach to the assessment of asylum claims contained in the Qualification and Procedures Directives.

Importantly and for the first time it is accepted at the level of the Supreme court that asylum is not a matter of discretion, but one which must be decided on the evidence before a tribunal or a court. The court has left open the question whether judicial review in the UK is an effective remedy for the purposes of Union law.

The court offered too that tracing may continue to have relevance even after a child has notionally reached adulthood. Claimant lawyers may find support in the court’s ruling for requests to adjourn proceedings so that investigations, with government help, may be completed before final determination of an asylum claim. Claimant lawyers may wish to explore the exercise of public law remedies to compel government to gather evidence in support of a child’s asylum claim.

Becket Bedford
24th June 2015

Click here to view Becket Bedford's profile.

Click here to view the UKSC Judgment

Related articles

Personal Injury analysis: This analysis considers Master Cook’s judgment in RXK in which he sets out the circumstances in which the court will order an interim payment despite final quantification still being some years hence. It explains why this will be welcome news for claimant solicitors, even though no substantive decision was given in the case....

Date: Wed, 04 Dec 2019
No5 Barristers’ Chambers joined forces with Moore Blatch Solicitors to host an “inspiring evening” to mark the centenary of women in law....

Date: Thu, 28 Nov 2019
In her article published today in the New Law Journal, “Duty of care: Inadequate safety nets?"...

Date: Fri, 19 Jul 2019